Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14

Black Desert Online and Final Fantasy 14 are large-scale fantasy MMORPG games, which feature tons of PvE content and unique gameplay mechanics. These projects have many things in common, such as immersive story-oriented gameplay and advanced guild systems. However, these games differ dramatically in terms of storyline, combat system, raids and other activities loved by players. It's not easy to decide which of them is better, but there are several aspects which can be compared.

Briefly about Final Fantasy 14

Final Fantasy XIV is a massively multiplayer online role-playing game developed and published by Square Enix. FF14 relies heavily on plot and character history development, so the game has a vast amount of PvE content. The structure of the narrative is harmoniously linked to the player's exploration of the locations and their inhabitants.

By exploring each zone, players are immersed in the history of the world and move closer to their destination. There are dozens of different biomes, and each part of the universe is unique. The trial version of MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV includes the content of the Heavensward expansion, and the maximum level that can be reached in the trial is 60.

After its release in 2010, Final Fantasy 14 was considered as one of the worst online games in history. The project was ruined by a lot of bugs, low-quality and high-demanding graphics, small amount of content and uncomfortable character development system. After a while, developers completely redesigned the gameplay and released A Realm Reborn expansion, which restored the reputation of the game.

Final Fantasy 14

Briefly about the Black Desert Online

Black Desert is a fantasy MMORPG that combines elements of several game genres: real-time strategy, role-playing game and life simulator. A distinctive feature of this project is a large-scale combat system that requires well-coordinated teamwork and correct strategic decisions. Also, the game has a seamless open world, full freedom of character editor and much more.

In BDO, players will have to explore a world filled with unique activities, create different playable characters and choose between a dozen different classes. Battles in the game are based on a non-targeted combat system, which is similar to single-player action games. The player needs to keep the enemies in sight, strike them and evade their attacks. Black Desert Online is included in the list of the most popular games in the MMORPG genre.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Quest system

Each chain of quests in Final Fantasy 14 corresponds to a certain NPC who will tell different stories tied to the main storyline, which uncovers the mystery of the Eorzea. These quests are not just flashbacks or plain text told by NPCs, but the action is cleverly woven into the new lore and storyline with its highlights — especially the final missions.

In Shadowbringers appeared the so-called Role Quests, which came to replace the quests of Professions. New skills are now obtained with the development of levels and completion of different challenges.

There are many quests in BDO; first of all, it is worth to perform quests from the Black Spirit. Many missions open in the process of increasing the level of character, craft, for others, you need to get friendship points with the NPCs. BDO, like many other MMORPG games, is not limited to the mandatory completion of tasks and quests. Even without them, any player can develop his character or engage in trade, fishing, cooking, alchemy, etc.

After completing quests, you get experience, influence points, materials, various valuable items and other special rewards. It is also the best way to explore the game world.

Story missions in BDO also have an impressive story to play in. For their completion, the dark spirit offers the most valuable reward. You can get weapons or armour, experience, skill points, expanding equipment slots, inlay stones, scrolls for extra EXP, jewellery and much more. After completing the Black Desert story tasks, you can get several useful items at once.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Character Customization

Character creation in Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn is typical for most MMORPGs. The settings are sufficiently detailed to create a unique character without going too deep into details. Players can adjust the height, facial features, voice, hairstyle, facial hair and many other features. It's also necessary to choose a date of birth on a mystical calendar of 12 months, as well as select the "Defender" or a deity, which will change the statistics of resistance to some elements.

  • Hyur — a human-like race that inhabits most of the world Final Fantasy 14. One of the features of Hyur is their cultural diversity and developed social institutions.
  • Elezen — a peaceful elflike race who inhabited the continent for the longest time. The Duskwight Elezen prefer to live in caves, because of which they have developed an acute hearing. The Wildwood Elezen live on the surface in the forests of Eorzea.
  • Lalafell — a gnome-like race from the seas south of Eorzea. This race is divided into the Plainsfolk and Dunesfolk who live in the desert.
  • Miqo'te — a feline humanoid race that can be found in almost every region. They divide into the Seekers of the Sun and the Keepers of the Moon.
  • Roegadyn — a race of maritime creatures who live at the north seas of Eorzea. These giantlike people often become mercenaries or pirates.
  • Au Ra — the first original race of Final Fantasy 14. There are two clans for the Au Ra: the bright-scaled Au Ra Raen and dark-scaled Au Ra Xaela.

Adjusting the appearance of the hero allows you to choose the body type, face Type and advanced settings. In this section, you can adjust your age, eye colour, which tattoos will be on your character, choose jewellery, and a hairstyle or a beard. Here you can also choose one of the voices of your character, and improve the face of your character.

To create a character in the Black Desert online, you need to click on the button "Create" in the upper right corner of the screen. One account can contain up to 12 characters at a time, seven slots — free, the rest must be purchased in the game store.

You can read a brief description of each class, view battle styles and learn their strengths and weaknesses using the pentagonal chart.
The main stage of the character creation is the adjustment of its appearance: hairstyle, face and body. There are both ready-made models of faces and hairstyles, and an advanced editor, so you can experiment with the style of the character for a very long time. You can save the result at any time of editing and return it in case of an error. You can also create a layout (or preset) of your character and share it with other players, or you can use presets created by other players.

The "View" button in the upper left corner is responsible for the direction of your character's view (either he is looking at the mouse cursor or right in front of him). The "Menu" button hides/shows the editor interface. In addition to changing the appearance of the character, you can see how he will look in different lighting conditions.

The next steps to create a character are to specify its future name (bottom right corner, under the last name) and choose a constellation. Depending on the chosen constellation, your character will have different relations with the NPC. After selecting a constellation, it will be displayed on the right side of the screen.

After you finish, you will be able to see what your character will look like in different poses and suits. You can do this with the "Actions" function. Once you have decided on your chosen role, you need to click on the "Create" button.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Combat System

The gameplay of Final Fantasy 14 will be familiar to all players who once ran MMORPG. First, you need to choose one of the six races, and most importantly, you need to decide on the class. A total of 8 classes are available, among which five deal damage with weapons and the rest prefer to deal with enemies using the magic. The choice of the class also determines the available quests and the location from which the player starts the game.

The combat system of FF14 is real-time and is different for PVP and PVE battles, but in general, it is based on building long combos. There are only a few types of attacks available: standard weapon attacks with a rollback of 2.5 seconds, magic and special abilities. In battle, you have to constantly monitor the scales of attacks and choose the skills suitable for certain opponents. The type of attack depends on the chosen class; therefore, in battles against large mobs, it's better to choose a team with different abilities.

Battle system is based on the application of skills on a rather global cooldown in two and a half seconds (in this interval you can fit a couple of special skills, which have their own timer), and most of the boss fights require the correct positioning — and the main aspect here is to combine running with the issuance of maximum damage.

The combat system has been seriously updated, and gameplay was generally optimized with the redesign of technique points. From now on, the use of magical skills requires mana points. An important parameter for healers, Piety, now does not affect the amount of mana and is tied to the speed of its recovery.

As for BDO, the developers managed to make the system Black Desert Online close to single games, it is dynamic and not subject to problems with animation, which often interfere with players in other projects. From the first minutes of the game, killing monsters does not seem a routine, as usually happens in MMO: you can aim, choose hideouts, bypass the enemy, combine jerks with blows. You can take a bow and shoot enemies from afar, or fight a crowd near you.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Dungeons and Raids

All challenges in Final Fantasy 14 are closed, isolated instances: dungeons, raids, battles with the bosses. Players have to cooperate in groups of fixed composition: for example, in a simple dungeon, you need one tank (gathers enemies and uses high protection and appropriate skills to survive their attacks), one healer (heals and resurrects) and two damagers (these heroes deal lots of damage). The bosses and raids require a team of eight people with two tanks, two healers and four damagers. Access to raid content is available even in the free version of the game.

In Black Desert Online there are no standard dungeons and raids, except with the Guild instances. Instead, BDO has powerful world bosses with a huge stock of health and an impressive attack. You can earn good money by killing them, as well as fighting with field bosses. World bosses appear on a strictly defined schedule in certain places marked on the world map.

Field bosses in BDO are easier to kill, but they provide less loot. As for their spawning, there is no clear schedule, and they spawn by accident somewhere in the world—the average spawning frequency is once a day. The health of such a boss on each channel is counted separately, so you can kill a field boss several times by switching to another server.

BDO world bosses appear simultaneously on all channels. They are cross-server, the health level of the general and is reduced by the damage caused by all the players who came into battle. For consistency of actions that led to the murder of the boss, the best warriors are generously rewarded. Being a member of a raid or group is not necessary: it does not affect the reward.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: PvP

Although PvP is not the most popular aspect of FFXIV, it's quite immersive. Developers regularly twist the balance and add new modes, and the best players are invited to fan festivals for show fights. PvP is another way to pump up and earn the necessary resources for development. All modes are available after receiving the profession, even in the free version of the game.

Before going to the match, you need to distribute PvP attacks on PvP-bars, as well as select additional abilities and bonuses. All this is done through the menu Character > PvP Profile. Each profession has its own set of attacks and abilities; it is necessary to study them in advance. The level and equipment do not matter; the parameters depend only on the selected profession.

In Black Desert Online, PvP battles are based on confrontation guilds. Battles take place in the open world, and siege and territorial battles involving a huge number of players are the most important element. The game also has a karma system. Karma is charged for killing players, but if your clans are in an official war, there are no penalties. Penalties are given for killing horses and some NPCs that act like ordinary citizens and don't attack players but are necessary to complete quests.

At level 30 in BDO, your character will be able to attack other players. Just like other players, they will be able to attack you as well. To activate the PvP mode, click on the icon with two crossed swords.

To correct your karma level, you need to kill a lot of monsters, and it's better to do it in the game; it's faster and safer because the character with high karma is an excellent target for hunting players. The higher your level, the more experience you will lose, and the worse your karma, the higher your chances to lose things.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Endgame Content

In Final Fantasy 14, you can explore the world, fight monsters, complete quests — all like in the usual RPG. Quests in the game are not reduced to "talk to such an NPC" or "beat somebody". Their essence is not to challenge, but to introduce the player to the local world and characters. After completion of the main content, you can develop other classes, fight in PvP, collect mounts, hunt rare and powerful monsters. Also, the game has unique Challenge: special dungeons - "roguelike", treasure hunting on maps, customization of your own house or apartment, mini-games on the attractions. Besides, you may be engaged in chocolate breeding, racing, gathering, fishing, and kraft.

Black Desert Online has a huge number of different activities and exciting tasks that form the endgame content. After completing the main part of the game, you can focus on playing PvP, polishing skills and equipment of your character, or fight with the bosses. There are also various PvP activities in the game - the advanced craft system allows you to hire workers and equip workshops at home with your character, fishing, growing food on the farm and much more.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Social Features

Free Company is a guild or clan in Final Fantasy XIV. They are accepted from the first level and are ready to answer the questions of beginners. These organizations are created by ordinary players. They are distinguished primarily by the fact that a player can be a member of only one organization at a time. The second difference is the possibility for the players to purchase land and build their base on it. Also, for performing various tasks, the players get special points which they can be exchanged for some items.

The players of Free Company can access a chest, which stores the treasures gained by the players during their adventures. There are also bonuses of the organization in the form of additional experience, for example. And the most pleasant bonus is, of course, its own Guildhouse. All players in the organization will be able to visit the house, communicate there, share experiences and store their belongings in personal chests.

Guild houses in BDO are not only and not only military organizations, but also commercial structures and associations of interested players. Guilds can have unique clan houses, unique quests and other bonuses.

Each member of the guild who does something in the game receives points for the activity in the guild. Among the activities not related to the guild, the greatest influence is the increase in the level of the character. For example, you get EXP when you develop a hero or promote professional skills.

The size of the guild affects the available quests - the more the guild, the more missions are available for it. Most of them are the same as the usual side quests, but some tasks have more monsters to destroy or resources to be extracted in the allotted time. A large guild can also perform small quests, but a small guild has no access to larger quests. The size of the quest depends on how many points the guild receives.

Even if you are not a member of the guild, you still have access to many social functions. For example, you can buy several houses in Black Desert Online to get influence points. The house is a perforated room, which can be used as a warehouse, processing shop or living room. You can place several rooms of different players in the same house. It is possible to buy several houses and place furniture in them. The houses are located in every major city. Low-level characters can buy only small rooms, but most of them have good conditions.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Music

Music in FFXIV is very important — it strongly influences other elements of the project. The compositions are dominated by symphonic sounding, chorus and powerful female vocals. The music of the original game was written by the famous composer Nobuo Uematsu, who managed to convey the breathtaking adventures of endless Final Fantasy. Whether it's a battle melody, victorious fanfares, a passionate song of the final battle of the quest or lullaby trills, you will always soar in this all-consuming atmosphere of miracles and wanderings. Composer Masayoshi Soken has been writing music for FFXIV since the very beginning of its restart, and he has as many genius compositions as he has diverse. You will not find such eclecticism, variety of styles and sound anywhere else.

At the time of release, Black Desert Online was one of the games with better graphics; over the years, the game has received a remastered version with improved visual quality and many new features. Black Desert Online 2018 Remastered includes physical rendering, improved lighting and atmospheric dispersion, volumetric clouds, HDR rendering, improved post-processing, improved reflection and surface shading, improved ocean rendering and a clothing simulator. The remastering version of the game includes more than 220 music tracks lasting over 660 minutes, seven full albums - one for each continent, recorded by orchestras.

Black Desert Online vs Final Fantasy 14: Graphics & System Requirements

Graphics of Final Fantasy 14 are unique and outstanding because of their authentic visual style and elements of the universe. Only in this game, you can find mighty Mages in pointy hats, cute little Lalafell, and funny birdlike pets Chocobo. The character designs of FF14 are inspired by anime and art of the Japanese artist Yoshitaka Amano. Final Fantasy 14 also features huge detailed locations, realistic landscapes and unique biomes. FF14 can be run even on low-end PCs and consoles, which allows players to play it if they don't have enough resources to run complex games.

Final Fantasy 14 Recommened Requirements

  • Memory: 8 GB
  • Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 970
  • CPU: Intel Core i7 (3.0 GHz) or better
  • File Size: 60 GB
  • OS: Windows 10 (64-bit)

Black Desert Online was initially promoted as the most beautiful MMORPG with a great emphasis on graphics quality. The game features a huge open world filled with a variety of details, photorealistic textures, detailed complex models of characters and armour, and much more. Also, the most famous feature of BDO is its character editor: artists from Pearl Abyss have invested weeks and weeks of work and polishing into it. The original project runs without problems with the medium settings, but the Remastered version on good settings is available only to owners of high-end PCs — if you try to run the Black Desert Online 2018 Remastered on a weak computer, you will have to endure unpleasant FPS drawdown in battles with the bosses.

Black Desert Online Recommended Requirements

  • Memory: 8 GB RAM
  • Graphics Card: GTX 970, AMD RX 480
  • CPU: Intel Core i5-650 3.2GHz
  • File Size: 27 GB
  • OS: Windows 7 or higher (64-bit)

Which One is Better?

Even though the basic aspects of Black Desert Online and Final Fantasy are pretty similar, these games are still very different. If you prefer to explore the deep lore, interact with NPCs to uncover the secrets of the game, and immerse into the storyline with different kinds of quests than your choice is Final Fantasy 14. This game has a free trial with all main content up to level 60, so you will have plenty of time to decide if you want to play further. If you prefer hardcore PvP battles, grind, deep crafting and resource management, then you may want to try Black Desert Online — this game features all these aspects.

Who is the winner?

Black Desert Online
1 votes
Final Fantasy 14
14 votes